Monday, 6 February 2012

Theory 2: Semiotics (Week 4)


Analytical Text – A logo of “Green Tomorrow”

To begin with, sign generally implies something that intended to have a meaning. In other words, there is a relationship between that something for example an object itself and its meaning. An object could not be considered as a sign if it does not entail a meaning. The question is where does sign comes from? Obviously, sign is one of the creations of human being. It is human who provide meaning to that particular object. However, a sign can only be created if it is culturally acceptable because that particular sign need to be understood by people – which is refer as a code.  


For example, a recent and well-known issue of global warming has raised the concern of people throughout the world and thus many organisations attempt to conduct campaigns to save the earth from pollution. In this case, the above logo of “green tomorrow” can be used to analyse how far it can be understood and considered as a sign.


Firstly, signifier and signified need to be identified to form a sign in the logo. The signifier is everything that can be seen in the logo. Then, a mental concept is created through the signifier called a signified. The signified in this context could be save the plants, protect the earth from harms or prevent global warming. Thus, the above logo is also seen as a sign because it symbolise a step to prevent from global warming. The whole logo represents “Support and Protect, Bio-degrade and Recycle, Green”.


 Apart from that, denotation could also form along with the sign or signifier – the factual description of the object. Instead of just saying a logo, there is green round shape, 2 hands holding a plant as well as a wording of “Green Tomorrow”. Once the logo has been denoted, it can then be conceptualised depending on how individual sees it – called connotation.


According to Marcel Danesi (2004), a sign can be referred as referent. There are 2 types of referent which are concrete referent and abstract referent.  A concrete referent is something that can be shown in real world but on the other hand abstract referent is only the imaginary thing usually refers to ideas which can be easily perceived. Simply saying, some logo can interpret the meaning of the sign in the picture directly but some others have the ability to influence people to anchor the meaning of the signs. In this context, it is believed that everyone can connote the sign directly such as from the wording “Green tomorrow”.


However, as stated by Daniel Chandler (2002). Saussure argued that signs refer to purely structural and relational rather than referential. Saussure said that no signs can make sense on its own but it has a systematic relation to each other. Instead of just analysing the whole picture in the logo as a sign, the symbols in the logo can also be analysed into details. In other words, the whole logo and the symbols are related. For instance, the two hands holding a plant (signifier) represents that it is the responsibility of the society to protect the ecosystems from further damage while the green round shape indicates that save the earth and the ecosystem. The whole logo implies the cooperation is needed to save the earth entirely and stop destroying the ecosystem.


Finally, sign can only be interpreted if it has object and meanings as well as widely accepted by the society. Danesi concluded that sign is based on referential where sign can be seen directly or through imagination. Nevertheless, Saussure stated that signs should be based on structural and relational where signs must have relation with each other and it cannot make sense of its own.